There is no menu. You look at the case of whatever came in that day, a server tells you the fish, the sides and the wine in that order, and you say grilled or fried. That's the whole operation, run by Elias and his brother, and it has been the same for decades at 24-02 31st Street, under the N/W at Astoria Boulevard. The octopus is the thing — creamy through the middle, charred outside, crisp at the thin end — and the whole branzino arrives with salt and lemon and nothing else, which is the entire argument.
HOW TO PLAY IT A Wednesday or Thursday is the night to walk in — the back patio is a weekend-group room and it empties out midweek. Order the grilled octopus, the fried sardines and one whole fish for the table; skip the appetiser sprawl and get taramasalata rather than the third dip. Ask what came in today before you pick the fish, and take the answer literally. Call ahead if there are more than four of you: 718-932-1510.